John McCreery
  • Yokohama, Japan
  • Japan
Share on Facebook
Share

John McCreery's Friends

  • Manal
  • Louise Krasniewicz
  • Peter Wogan
  • Matthew Timothy Bradey
  • Muhammad Waqas
  • Mentor Mahmuti
  • Larry Stout
  • Mott T  Greene
  • George D Baca
  • Tracey Thornborrow
  • Paul Wilson
  • Patience kabamba
  • Erin B. Taylor
  • Kate Wood
  • Johannes Lenhard

John McCreery's Discussions

Tim Ingold's "That's Enough About Ethnography"--The Seminar is Underway
109 Replies

Started this discussion. Last reply by John McCreery 8 hours ago.

Tim Ingold's "That's Enough About Ethnography"—Invitation to an informal seminar
9 Replies

Started this discussion. Last reply by John McCreery Mar 23.

HAU NOW!
2 Replies

Started this discussion. Last reply by John McCreery Jul 9, 2014.

 

John McCreery's Page

Latest Activity

John McCreery replied to ryan anderson's discussion What draws us to anthropology (and why an anthropological education matters)
"Ryan, I partially agree. Articulating the stories and histories that no one else has been willing to hear is, however, only part of what anthropology does as part of the broadest (worldwide, everywhere) and deepest (from hominids to homo…"
4 hours ago
John McCreery replied to John McCreery's discussion Tim Ingold's "That's Enough About Ethnography"--The Seminar is Underway
"The seminar appears to be winding down. I don't know about you, but I have had a great time listening in and participating in this conversation. So I have a few questions for you? 1. Shall we do it again? It is easy to do, just find a paper of…"
8 hours ago
John McCreery replied to ryan anderson's discussion What draws us to anthropology (and why an anthropological education matters)
"Suggest a look at k-12 education, especially high-school for college-bound kids. My own experience is likely totally out of date, but when I set off for Michigan State in 1962, I knew that I should study more math, science, languages, and history,…"
9 hours ago
John McCreery replied to John McCreery's discussion Tim Ingold's "That's Enough About Ethnography"--The Seminar is Underway
"Lee, I don't buy your description of the engineer's background or his likely response to what the anthropologist has to tell him. I am, for my sins, a member of a club where I have met, dined, and had long conversations with several…"
21 hours ago
Lee Drummond replied to John McCreery's discussion Tim Ingold's "That's Enough About Ethnography"--The Seminar is Underway
"Kristian, John, Huon,   David Gellner:  Methodologically, I argue that there is an irresolvable tension, an ‘antinomy’, between our small-scale, local methods as ethnographers, on the one side, and the global links and forces…"
yesterday
John McCreery replied to John McCreery's discussion Tim Ingold's "That's Enough About Ethnography"--The Seminar is Underway
"Kristian, very nice, indeed. This is what I call serious debate. Let me step back though and see if anyone else will step up and join the conversation."
yesterday
Kristian Garthus-Niegel replied to John McCreery's discussion Tim Ingold's "That's Enough About Ethnography"--The Seminar is Underway
"Appreciate the push John. The way the case study is tied to general social theory here is highly presumptuous; the reader is left with multiple intermediate layers to tie up. Uninformed as most of us are about the context, the conclusion may be full…"
yesterday
John McCreery replied to John McCreery's discussion Tim Ingold's "That's Enough About Ethnography"--The Seminar is Underway
"Kristian, I like the way you think. But let me push back a bit. Let us agree that Gellner's use of "experience" is weak and imprecise. There is, however, a plausible reading of what he is talking about that raises the question, Who…"
yesterday
Kristian Garthus-Niegel replied to John McCreery's discussion Tim Ingold's "That's Enough About Ethnography"--The Seminar is Underway
"Thanks for the link John. Gellner’s piece stands out as an example par excellence of the data-theory schism accumulated over the later 3 decades by the pervasive disdain for thinking systematically about what anthropologists do during…"
yesterday
Huon Wardle replied to John McCreery's discussion Tim Ingold's "That's Enough About Ethnography"--The Seminar is Underway
""There is a an inescapable Kantian antinomy, a necessary contradiction if you will, between seeing humans as constrained and embodying social forces that pre-exist them and as agents, able to shape and contest their future to some degree. The…"
yesterday
John McCreery replied to John McCreery's discussion Tim Ingold's "That's Enough About Ethnography"--The Seminar is Underway
"I have just discovered a piece by David Gellner in the most recent issue of Anthropology of this Century (AOTC) that relates both to Kristian's research and to the issues we have been discussing […"
Sunday
Erin B. Taylor replied to John McCreery's discussion Tim Ingold's "That's Enough About Ethnography"--The Seminar is Underway
"Lee, great story! I agree that ethnography not the problem when it comes to public communication. The main problem is that most anthropologists have little idea how to communicate about their discipline from someone from outside their discipline.…"
Saturday
John McCreery replied to John McCreery's discussion Tim Ingold's "That's Enough About Ethnography"--The Seminar is Underway
"Lee, Ouch! Wicked! Pointed humor, Indeed.  Allow me, however, in my own plodding way to address a difficulty that many of us, but especially Kristian, have with Ingold's article. We may find his programmatic statements appealing; but…"
Saturday
Lee Drummond replied to John McCreery's discussion Tim Ingold's "That's Enough About Ethnography"--The Seminar is Underway
"  Ethnography -- and Anthropology’s Public Voice   All, First, let me clear the air a bit.  During the Forum I’ve made some critical remarks about Ingold’s article – and I’ll now weigh it with more…"
Friday
Huon Wardle replied to John McCreery's discussion Tim Ingold's "That's Enough About Ethnography"--The Seminar is Underway
"Yes, agreed; with the proviso that one person's 'poetry' is often another's 'verifiable fact' and a third person's 'dangerous ideology'. But, on that, I can't resist paraphrasing somewhat…"
Friday
Kristian Garthus-Niegel replied to John McCreery's discussion Tim Ingold's "That's Enough About Ethnography"--The Seminar is Underway
"Thanks for your patience Huon. To me, the "magic"-ness lies primarily in the obscurity/meta-physical-ness of the concepts that dominate the disciplines internal discourses on what's better/worse anthro-crafts. Such as Ingold's;…"
Friday

Profile Information

Full Name (no screen names or handles)
John McCreery
School/Organization/Current anthropological attachment
Independent Scholar, Executive Committee AJJ
Website
http://www.wordworks.jp

John McCreery's Photos

Loading…
  • Add Photos
  • View All

John McCreery's Blog

Some people take culture seriously. Why?

With a tip of the hat to Bill Bishop at Sinocism,

Cultural reflection can improve modern governance: Xi - Xinhuaat Politburo study session  //  Xi argued that ancient ideologies still have deep influence on people nowadays, and they should be scientifically analyzed so as to inherit and promote the good parts…

Continue

Posted on October 16, 2014 at 8:33am

Why should I read what you have written?

Why should anyone read what you have written? This should be question No. 1 for anyone writing anything. So, let me rephrase the question: Why do so many of the contributors to the online forums in which I participate assume that people will be interested in what they are writing about, then feel disappointed when no one responds?

As students, we learn to write assignments. The teacher who hands us a topic has to read what we write. But once we leave school and start writing for…

Continue

Posted on October 15, 2014 at 9:41am

The Third International Conference on Applications of Anthropology in Business

     It was my third time to participate in the annual International Conference on Applications of Anthropology in Business, organized by Robert Tian Guang and held at a venue in China, and my second time to visit Jishou University, which is located in the Xiangxi Tujia and Miao Autonomous Prefecture in Hunan Province in the west of China. The first two…

Continue

Posted on May 23, 2014 at 4:30am

Who says anthropology can't rock?

Serendipitously, the entertainment section in this morning's Japan Times carries an article about an Indie band, three young Japanese women, called Crunch. One of them, Noriyo Hotta says,



"For example, take 'Mori no Naka,' the first track on the album. This song was influenced by Radiohead, especially the songs 'Jigsaw Falling' and 'There There,' and a funk tune by Japanese rock band Jagatara called 'Tango.' But I was also inspired by a book about the Yanomami tribe in the Amazon.… Continue

Posted on March 5, 2014 at 3:06am

Collective? Individual? Both? How should we think about thinking?

Just found an interesting piece titled "Good Group Think" on eighteen chains.com. Resurrects some shrewd observations by Karl Mannheim, from Ideology and Utopia. Most of what we think we learn from others. We add a bit and pass it on. Tracing the routes is a project called the sociology of knowledge. Enjoy. Reflect. Respond. Pass it on.

Posted on February 3, 2014 at 8:29am — 7 Comments

Comment Wall (32 comments)

You need to be a member of Open Anthropology Cooperative to add comments!

Join Open Anthropology Cooperative

At 6:52am on April 3, 2014, Peter Wogan said…

Thanks, John. Sorry to be away, but nice to know I'm missed! More to follow...

Peter

At 1:43pm on March 2, 2013, Larry Stout said…

The "Grey People" are found at yet another fishing village along the same coast of Gaspesie.  It's a very interesting and scenic drive, all the way around the peninsula.  You see the flag of Acadie flying there, and in parts of New Brunswick,often to the exclusion of the Canada flag.

At 12:17pm on March 2, 2013, Larry Stout said…

Hi, John  -- The "Blue Men" are the work of an old woodcarver who has a shop in a fishing village on the St. Lawrence seaway in Gaspé, Quebec.  He fashioned them from driftwood logs and gave them a beautiful lapis lazuli panache.  I told him that when I win the lottery I'll fly him down to Ozarkistan and pay him handsomely to create similar art for our backyard (near our inukshuk).

At 11:40pm on January 11, 2013, Tracey Thornborrow said…

thanks for that John, I shall check it out! 

At 11:30pm on November 8, 2012, Kate Wood said…

Sorry for the late response, I am not good at social networking! :) 

At 3:45am on September 15, 2012, Keith Hart said…
See OAC Facebook.
At 12:46pm on September 9, 2012, Sheyma Buali said…

sounds great, thanks a lot for the suggestion! im looking at it and it shall indeed be helpful!

At 3:16pm on June 28, 2012, Logan Sparks said…

thanks, John, for the article. its very interesting. I am actually looking into what else Neslihan Cevik has written...

At 2:41am on May 6, 2012, Chelsea Hayman said…

Thank you John for your excellent response and the great clarification! It's been awhile since those undergrad theory classes, but I did learn a lot from them, even though they were so long ago. Now I am trying to manage a theory class in my Master's course that was combined with ethnography -- except the weeks seem to be organized thematically rather than chronologically. Or in order of influence rather than historical period. All of this can be rather frustrating for a student, who can make misleading assumptions based on when the material was presented! All very confusing. Thank you for sorting that information out for me - we did not discuss the Boasians at length in my class but rather focused mostly upon Geertz. Such is the nature of the British school of Anthropology. I'll have to post more blogs about theory - I always have lots of questions and need for clarification. I wish I had more time to learn about the historical context in which some of these ideas developed, but I should have plenty of time when I graduate to read freely. :)

At 11:44am on March 21, 2012, Chelsea Hayman said…

John, firstly, thank you for all of your input. I completely agree with what you said about the 'Western' - the idea is pretty totalizing and inaccurate in and of itself. I've been looking into more ontological theory and non-dualism since I've been studying for my Master's. I think it's easy to set up a dichotomy almost as a polemical point of departure and I guess I have been using it more evocatively in thinking through some of the ideas that have been on my mind for the past couple of weeks. I will look into the material you suggested and see what I can come up with. I suppose my main issue with conceptual categories is that they can be so linguistically conditioned, but they also have some grounding in our ideas about rationality, which can also be variable depending upon one's education. I think that's an idea I've been struggling with. I don't necessarily think the authors are arguing against that point, but it seems to be an often unidentified issue in the cognitive science literature. Of course, the anthropological literature addresses it rather well, on the whole. What are you up to in Japan? I see that you work as an independent scholar - what kinds of work do you do? I'm interested because I've considered a non-academic career in applied anthropology. Thank you again for your input, I appreciate it greatly.

 
 
 

Translate

OAC Press

@OpenAnthCoop

© 2015   Created by Keith Hart.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service