M Izabel
  • Female
  • Philippines
Share on Facebook
Share Twitter

M Izabel's Friends

  • Erin B. Taylor
  • Abraham Heinemann
  • Debaprasad Bandyopadhyay
  • Ken Routon
  • Logan Sparks
  • Alexander Lee
  • heesun hwang
  • A. Ashkuff
  • Meenakshie VERMA
  • LIviaFilotico
  • NIKOS GOUSGOUNIS
  • Stacy A A Hope
  • John McCreery
  • Layla AbdelRahim
  • Keith Hart

M Izabel's Discussions

An Attack On Cultural Anthropology
41 Replies

A guy (maybe a geneticist/biologist) from this site,  …Continue

Started this discussion. Last reply by John McCreery May 2.

Geekiness or Nerdiness: Is It A Culture?
11 Replies

First off, I don't mean to ruffle feathers.  I know SV is currently talking about it.  Unfortunately, I have to open a Facebook or Twitter account before I can post a comment on their temporary site.…Continue

Started this discussion. Last reply by The Geek Anthropologist Apr 11.

Is Anthropology A Science?
26 Replies

One of my hobbies is reading scientific journals.  I like reading The Lancet, for example, to keep myself abreast with latest medical breakthroughs.  I sense five methods scientists/researchers use…Continue

Started this discussion. Last reply by John McCreery Mar 21.

Can we really understand a cultural/social phenomenon using just one theoretical framework or specific analytical tool/lens?
20 Replies

It is pretty obvious that culture is a web of causes and effects, big and small, and society is a web of groups and institutions, organized and chaotic, yet I still read texts that peddle a specific…Continue

Started this discussion. Last reply by Youdheya Banerjee/Bandyopadhyay Oct 3, 2011.

 

M Izabel's Page

Latest Activity

John McCreery replied to M Izabel's discussion An Attack On Cultural Anthropology
"From LinkedIn A great quote from Isaac Asimov covers some of this: "How often people speak of art and science as though they were two entirely different things, with no interconnection. An artist is emotional, they think, and uses only his…"
May 2
NIKOS GOUSGOUNIS replied to M Izabel's discussion An Attack On Cultural Anthropology
"5/ and last  ( but not least) :  Anthropology  IS a science exactly because  in the middle  of the objectivity/subjectivity scale (and this  is not an axiom but an objective note even if reflects a subjective opinion of…"
May 2
NIKOS GOUSGOUNIS replied to M Izabel's discussion An Attack On Cultural Anthropology
"conclusions  : 1/ Economy is nowhere in Huon's scale  not even after ...lyrical poetry and this is not accidental. If this scale is too much anglosaxonic that  means  that  Economy is PURE ideology and subjective…"
May 2
John McCreery replied to M Izabel's discussion An Attack On Cultural Anthropology
"Which is not to put down Newton. He was a genuine genius, one of the greatest ever, but also a man of his times. He envisioned a clockwork universe. We now envision the universe as more like a nuclear reactor, a biochemical stew, or the endless…"
May 1
John McCreery replied to M Izabel's discussion An Attack On Cultural Anthropology
"I wonder how many of our fans of simple, mechanical models know that Newton wrote more pages of astrology and alchemy than physics...."
May 1
Keith Hart replied to M Izabel's discussion An Attack On Cultural Anthropology
"This is because modern economics was invented in England in the 17th century (in response to the removal of the king's head as authority for all public decisions) and hasn't moved on since. Neiother has Anglo empiricism, despite Kant,…"
May 1
John McCreery replied to M Izabel's discussion An Attack On Cultural Anthropology
"Here, from the Motley Fool, is one of the best descriptions of why markets don't work the way we think they do that I have seen recently.…"
May 1
Keith Hart replied to M Izabel's discussion An Attack On Cultural Anthropology
"This has got to be tongue in cheek, Huon. It is so Anglo of a certain period, like 1840 to 1980. In French or German it would be nonsense. Whoever said that knowledge of literature could not be systematic (science or Wissenschaft)? "
Apr 30
M Izabel replied to Huon Wardle's discussion The Park of 9: New OACpress paper and seminar 22nd April onwards. Seminar now open.
""The problem with seeing sharing everywhere is, as Huon suggests, to underplay the individual side of the individual/collective pair. This bias belongs to the tradition of believing that, in a market or capitalist society, the scarce factor is…"
Apr 30
John McCreery replied to M Izabel's discussion An Attack On Cultural Anthropology
"The curve looks right. Whether it should run from objective (verifiable) to subjective (emotional) could, however, be debated. Is classic ethnography (Malinowski, E-P, Gluckman,Turner, etc.) subjective or emotional? Are Hercule Poirot, Miss Marple,…"
Apr 30
Huon Wardle replied to M Izabel's discussion An Attack On Cultural Anthropology
Apr 30
NIKOS GOUSGOUNIS replied to M Izabel's discussion An Attack On Cultural Anthropology
"AGREE  AS  YOU PUT  IT "
Apr 30
John McCreery replied to M Izabel's discussion An Attack On Cultural Anthropology
"Didn't mean to say that anthropology has replaced rhetoric. The thought is that, if you see academic disciplines as distributed along a continuum from more precise (mathematical science) to less precise (rhetorical narrative), what…"
Apr 30
NIKOS GOUSGOUNIS replied to M Izabel's discussion An Attack On Cultural Anthropology
" "
Apr 30
John McCreery replied to M Izabel's discussion An Attack On Cultural Anthropology
"All arguments make assumptions? Yes. All models involve simplifications? Yes. Do assumptions + simplifications equal science? No. If they did, theology would be a science. It isn't. The scientific question always has to do with the relationship…"
Apr 29
M Izabel replied to M Izabel's discussion An Attack On Cultural Anthropology
"Here's a good reading about prior assumptions in Economics--that "rationality implies the common prior assumptions," for  example.   http://www.econ.yale.edu/~dirkb/teach/pdf/morris/commonprior.pdf Those assumptions and…"
Apr 29

Profile Information

Full Name (no screen names or handles)
M Izabel

M Izabel's Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

M Izabel's Blog

On Chagnon and My Field Experience

First off, power scares and sickens me.  I don't associate myself with people who relish and strive for it. Power-trippers make my blood boil and turn me into a confrontational savage.

I was a victim of departmental politics years ago, and it was an experience I would not wish on the worst of my enemies.  It was the first time I got disillusioned with anthropology as my chosen career.  Anthropology, from studying to publishing, is a matter of numbers like politics, where the…

Continue

Posted on April 26, 2013 at 8:44am — 4 Comments

Theoretical Anthropology: Is It Possible?

The best thing here at OAC is that anyone can write a blog post or a comment or a discussion topic about anything as long as there's a discernible anthropology in it.  Other anthropology sites are too academic and formal; thus the posts and the comments seemed restrained, awfully familiar, and vanilla--that's not out of the box.  It makes me wonder if anthropologists in those sites are really sharing their best or if they are being careful not to sound unprofessional or come out unacademic.…

Continue

Posted on March 31, 2013 at 7:31am — 12 Comments

Anthropology of Sadness

I have been writing sad poems lately, and the sadness is not mine, but from the people I see and know.  I wonder how would an anthropologist write about sadness.  It is easy for a poet to be emotional since logic is not the foundation of poetry.  Can an anthropologist rely on his emotion about someone's feelings or sadness?  Since anthropology is a science, should logic supersede emotion?  I just don't think anyone can write about someone's sadness without empathy or sympathetic feelings.  I…

Continue

Posted on August 23, 2012 at 3:34am — 7 Comments

Anthropologizing Prehistory: Mutual Trust to Mutual Distrust in Exchange

While writing my last blog post, Losing To Win, I felt my assertions were somewhat vague and lacking in substance. Even though I hate copying and pasting citations and passages in quotations, I always try to find papers or books I can cite to support my views in case push comes to shove.  I hate when someone accuses me of relying on my opinions and irresponsibly passing them around as facts.

So, I…

Continue

Posted on August 7, 2012 at 10:18am — 1 Comment

Comment Wall (3 comments)

You need to be a member of Open Anthropology Cooperative to add comments!

Join Open Anthropology Cooperative

At 6:10pm on January 8, 2011, Toby Austin Locke said…
Hi Izabel,

I just wanted to take a minute to apologies for what turned into a rather short and frustrated exchange regarding the ‘Google ngram’ debate. We obviously hold very different opinions about a lot of subjects, when tiered or fatigued such clashes can cause me to become a little short tempered. My apologies if anything I said came across as rude or personal, this was not my intention. Our differences in opinion should be celebrated as it gives us both the opportunity to develop and examine them further. Anyway I hope nothing was taken personally or in the wrong context.

All the best

Toby
At 10:43pm on November 14, 2010, Michael Francis said…
I think online discussions can be problematic as tone intention etc can be misread easily. Hope I have not been rude back either. I do enjoy our discussions.
At 5:07pm on November 14, 2010, Michael Francis said…
No worries, I enjoyed are debate and will read up Lemkin as suggested.

I think my disagreement with the watering down comes from working with different groups of Bushmen some who have experienced a genocide and others language loss and cultural change some of it nasty, but it really strikes me a different.

And I really dislike Survival International's campaign against Botswana as it is really inaccurate and there are a series of blatant mis-truths (lies) in their claims. And they make use of words such as genocide and create hysteria to make their campaign work but really inaccurate and quite a racist representation of the Bushmen living isolation from the rest of the world.

Go well and I look forward to seeing/reading you online.
 
 
 

Translate

@OpenAnthCoop

© 2013   Created by Keith Hart.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service