Philip Swift
  • Male
  • London
  • United Kingdom
Share on Facebook
Share Twitter

Philip Swift's Friends

  • Richard Schweid
  • Kenneth Gibson
  • MAI Saptenno
  • Joel M. Wright
  • Amiria Salmond
  • Nicolette Makovicky
  • Steph Spittle
  • Neil Turner
  • Becky Bloom
  • Giovanni Bulian
  • NIKOS GOUSGOUNIS
  • Stacy A A Hope
  • John McCreery
  • Justin Shaffner
  • Huon Wardle

Philip Swift's Groups

 

Philip Swift's Page

Latest Activity

Philip Swift replied to Justin Shaffner's discussion New OAC Online Seminar: John Conroy Intimations of the 'informal economy', 16th April to 28th April
"A really interesting, illuminating essay, John. As an anthropologist whose knowledge of economics is sadly limited to what I get from 'experts' on nightly news programmes - where the expertise is generally presented as being somehow…"
Apr 26
Philip Swift commented on Logan Sparks's blog post bektashis, shared shrines and limited discourses
"Thanks Logan. I suppose what I was thinking about was how these divine figures are understood to inhabit the same space - or even the same 'body' as it were. In the Japanese case (which I'm sure John is familiar with) Buddhist…"
Apr 3
Philip Swift commented on Logan Sparks's blog post bektashis, shared shrines and limited discourses
"Your project sounds fascinating, Logan. The story about the dervish lodge reusing the building materials of the former Christian monastery prompts me to make a bad joke about 'brick-olage'. But more seriously, as you say, what looks like…"
Apr 2
Philip Swift replied to Huon Wardle's discussion OAC Press Working Paper 12: Thomas Sturm on Kant's cosmopolitan point of view in history.
"I must say I have enjoyed the seminar very much - the back and forth flow of the exchanges made all the better thanks to Thomas' precise responses.     One lesson I've learned is that the philosophical stereotypes we might all…"
Apr 2
Philip Swift replied to Huon Wardle's discussion OAC Press Working Paper 12: Thomas Sturm on Kant's cosmopolitan point of view in history.
"Thanks Thomas, for your thorough and enlightening reply.  I ought to say - partly in answer to Keith - that I didn't mean my point to be that, because Kant might have held some dubious views, it would invalidate his whole philosophy. I…"
Mar 23
Philip Swift replied to Huon Wardle's discussion OAC Press Working Paper 12: Thomas Sturm on Kant's cosmopolitan point of view in history.
"Thank you, Thomas, for your excellent and fine-grained paper.  I fear I don't know as much about Kant as I wish I did, which probably makes what I want to say dubious. But, regarding Kant's notion of cosmopolitanism, what I would…"
Mar 22
Victor Grauer commented on Philip Swift's blog post The Relevance of Anthropology? A Marxist Response
"Thanks so much, Huon, for that extremely interesting video clip. It's one of the most succinct and dramatic examples of a scientific experiment I've ever seen. Also quite convincing. But what it tells me is not (necessarily) that color…"
Dec 22, 2011
John McCreery commented on Philip Swift's blog post The Relevance of Anthropology? A Marxist Response
"Anyway, to get back to Boyer. His '3 modes of scholarship' model is, in my view, a self-serving, more or less rhetorical division designed to make his own position (cognitive science) seem reasonable and anthropology (at least, of the…"
Dec 3, 2011
Philip Swift commented on Philip Swift's blog post The Relevance of Anthropology? A Marxist Response
"Okay. Sorry I was away for a bit.  I won't wade into Berlin & Kay. Although, should anyone be interested, I think that Michael Forster's critique* of their thesis is pretty devastating. (Forster is not an anthropologist, but a…"
Dec 3, 2011
Huon Wardle commented on Philip Swift's blog post The Relevance of Anthropology? A Marxist Response
"As I say, the relevant bit is about 3 mins in..."
Dec 2, 2011
Huon Wardle commented on Philip Swift's blog post The Relevance of Anthropology? A Marxist Response
" "
Dec 2, 2011
Huon Wardle commented on Philip Swift's blog post The Relevance of Anthropology? A Marxist Response
"On reflection, let's take the categories as Boyer imposes them. The answer is that anthropology does now and has always used a mix of scientific, erudite and simply 'salient' ideas. It has had interesting debates about…"
Dec 2, 2011
Huon Wardle commented on Philip Swift's blog post The Relevance of Anthropology? A Marxist Response
"Unfortunately for Boyer, and Philip has pointed out various examples of this, the argument here is itself a good example of the 'salient connections' approach. In a rather attention-seeking way, Boyer, uses various rhetorics (including…"
Dec 2, 2011
Huon Wardle commented on Philip Swift's blog post The Relevance of Anthropology? A Marxist Response
"Unfortunately for Boyer, and Philip has pointed out various examples of this, the argument here itself a good example of the 'salient connections' approach. In a rather attention-seeking way, Boyer, uses various rhetorics (including guilt…"
Dec 2, 2011
John McCreery commented on Philip Swift's blog post The Relevance of Anthropology? A Marxist Response
"<previous comment continued>    6.There is no agreement on what constitutes competence, aside from lists of a few acknowledged       masters. Boyer's central argument is that cultural anthropology, once…"
Dec 2, 2011
John McCreery commented on Philip Swift's blog post The Relevance of Anthropology? A Marxist Response
"Huon, suppose we both settle down and conduct a proper debate on the ideas in Pascal Boyer's from studious irrelevancy to consilient knowledge: modes of scholarship and cultural anthropology1.  I emphasize the…"
Dec 2, 2011

Profile Information

Full Name (no screen names or handles)
Philip Swift
School/Organization/Current anthropological attachment
Independent

Philip Swift's Blog

The Relevance of Anthropology? A Marxist Response

 

The Relevance of Anthropology? A Marxist Response

 

 

Firefly: My friends, this man’s case moves me deeply. Look at Chicolini! He sits there alone, an abject…

Continue

Posted on November 26, 2011 at 3:30am — 23 Comments

Writing the riots

 

Just after ten o’clock on Monday night, there was the first intimation that trouble was coming: sounds of a mass moving up the street outside – a sense of heavy presence. Turning off the lights, I looked out of the window. Down below, some sixty people were milling about. The constituency of the crowd was mixed: some white, some black, some Asian, though mostly young men. Many of them were hooded, their faces further hidden behind bicycle breath-masks, bandanas, or more…

Continue

Posted on August 11, 2011 at 12:12am — 4 Comments

Phone Hacking, Sorcery and Parapolitics

 

‘My own view is, and I still hold with this view, that in terms of the reaction of people, the reaction is going to be primarily Washington and not the country because I think the country doesn’t give much of a shit about it other than the ones we've already bugged…most people around the country think that this is routine, that everyone’s trying to bug everyone else, it’s politics. That’s my view.’



This was Nixon, speaking in the Oval Office on the morning of the 21st…

Continue

Posted on August 1, 2011 at 5:18am — 6 Comments

The 'Perils of the Nation': The Activist Anthropology of Henry Mayhew









I want to tell you about Henry Mayhew. His work is neither new (he wrote during the same decades as Charles Dickens), nor was he an anthropologist, yet for all that, he produced a vital and urgent anthropology that speaks critically to our current moment.



Mayhew’s aim (in his own words) was to ‘publish the history of a people, from the lips of the people… Continue

Posted on November 16, 2010 at 6:30pm — 7 Comments

Comment Wall (5 comments)

You need to be a member of Open Anthropology Cooperative to add comments!

Join Open Anthropology Cooperative

At 11:14am on December 6, 2010, Stacy A A Hope said…
Hi Phillip!

I think that would be a great idea. You have creative freedom as to how your review may take shape. I will send you a private message with the rough guidelines.

Thank you for volunteering.

Stacy
At 12:07am on October 13, 2010, Jacob Lee said…
I just read your working paper Cosmetic cosmologies in Japan: Notes towards a superficial investigation. I enjoyed it very much and am looking forward to the seminar.
At 4:51am on June 8, 2010, Joel M. Wright said…
Thank you, Phillip.

I'm really enjoying your thread on hermeneutics.

Kudos to you, as it's not easy to argue in counterpoint to something that you agree with.
At 6:57pm on June 6, 2010, Neil Turner said…
Phillip,

Thank you for taking up the operative question in the debates. Now, we are debating.

tchau...
At 10:10pm on May 2, 2010, Keith Hart said…
Here is the essay by Bruce I was refferring to. Bruce Enlightenment.pdf

Bruce has a pamhlet for Sahlins's Prickly Paradigm series that is still forthcoming five years later. I am waiting for a paper he agreed to write for a conference i organized two years ago. That's par for Bruce. But we all forgive him for the sheer vitality of his spntaneous riffs.
 
 
 

Translate

@OpenAnthCoop



© 2012   Created by Keith Hart.   Powered by .

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service